Showing posts with label Comparisons. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Comparisons. Show all posts

Monday, May 6, 2013

Eyeliner Series: Liquid Eyeliner + Cheap Drugstore Formulas

     Here is my third post dedicated to eyeliner and it's staying power! I have already covered pencil liner (here) and felt-tip liner (here) so now we are on to the liquid formulation. Liquid liner can definitely be hard to get the hang of. I know that in the past I got into using felt-tip eyeliner everyday and when I switched back to liquid it would get everywhere during application! One of the pros of using liquid liner is that the line is usually more opaque and dark than pencil and felt-tip liners. As for a con, it can be hard to achieve a really precise wing with some applicators.

     As always, let's begin with the liquid liners you already own. I can honestly say that there aren't many great tips I can give you. Liquid liner tends to be pretty user friendly in the fact that things don't tend to dry out if not stored properly. You get an opaque, dark liner look with liquid liner but here are a few tips that can aid in the process.


Tip #1: Shake
Make sure you shake the product if you are instructed to do so by the directions. This ensures that the product is mixed well and that the line you get will be even and smooth. If the applicator also dips into the product shaking will coat the applicator evenly as well.

Tip #2: Technique
Make sure you work slowly and start in the middle or outer corner of your eye. I understand that for some, your technique of applying might be different but you want the majority of the product to be towards the outer portion of your lash line. If you begin with excess product on the applicator and apply it to your inner corner, too much color will deposit and you will be in trouble. For a beginner, keep the liner very thin towards the inner corner and get thicker as you work your way out- this is the most flattering look for any eye shape. Also make sure to look down into a mirror with your head tilted back. This position helps you to have perfect access to your lash line without getting it everywhere. You need to give the liner about 30 seconds to dry before opening your eye completely as well or you will be faced with liner transferring onto your lids!

Tip #3: Q-Tips
I actually keep a stash of these right next to me on my vanity. They come in handy with almost ANY makeup product but especially for liquid liner. If you mess up your wing or are dealing with transfer on your lids, whip one of these multi-tasking, simple tools out and you are good as gold. If your wing isn't pointy enough after application drag a damp q-tip from the outer corner of your eye to your eyebrow. This will clean things up and make your line very precise. If you have smudges or traces of liner in places that it's not supposed to be wait until it dries. This makes your life way easier! After about 30 seconds (or when you finish your liner look) take a damp q-tip and simply place the tip of it onto the spot and gently twist. This removes it completely without removing all of your foundation or eyeshadow.

     If you aren't satisfied with your current liner after trying the tips listed above here are two drugstore products that are worth trying...

From left to right:


 I first swatched the two products and let them set for a good 5 minutes.



Each was then tested on how the product smudged (top 1/2) as well as how it preformed while wet (lower 1/2). I did this by rubbing the top portion with medium pressure 3-5 times and doing the same with the lower portion but adding water to my finger.


Ranking Best-Worst:
1. Milani ($7.49)- This liquid liner ranked supreme during this test for sure. I have never seen a liquid liner that performs so well dry and wet! Even though this is the only shade in the line that doesn't contain sparkle it did it's job and outlasted my test. This liner is marketed to be a "long lasting, waterproof formula" and that it was! It didn't budge or smudge in the slightest but there was one downfall. The applicator is a little hard to work with. It is a very short, small, pointed tip that does not have any give to it what-so-ever. This makes application fairly difficult because once you make a line it is hard to go back over it. The applicator is so stiff that it sometimes removes product and leaves a line in the middle of your liner if you go over it again. Removing this was also more difficult as you will see later in this post. In my opinion, the only thing good about Milani's formula is it's staying power and being the topic of this post, I had to rank it #1 in that department.

2. Maybelline ($8.49)- This liner has a cult following for sure. Everyone practically loves it! From the photo above you can see that the liner didn't budge until water was present and that seems to be the story for the majority of these liners. If we weren't testing staying power I would rank this liner higher than Milani's because it is more user friendly. The applicator is more pliable and the line you get from it is easily achievable in one stroke. I will say that getting a pointy wing with this isn't the easiest thing to do so make sure you keep a q-tip within reach.

How well do they remove? Lets find out!
I used one Simple Cleansing Facial Wipe and documented the process from one wipe across - two!



You can see that the Maybelline formula is way easier to remove than Milani's. This is another plus for Maybelline's liner because you never want to have to scrub and tug at your eye area to remove your makeup. Once again though this post was about staying power and as you can see, Milani's does just that.



     I stopped at two wipes across because this swatch wasn't going anywhere. I did have to sit there and really scrub to get this off after this photo. However, I wore this liner once a few weeks ago and didn't find myself scrubbing TOO hard to remove it at the end of the day. Milani's liner comes off in flakes so you will end up with it everywhere but if you use a waterproof eye makeup remover you should be fine. It just takes a few extra minutes to remove but if you are in need of a long lasting liner, that is not a deal breaker.

     So that wraps up my post dedicated to liquid liners and their staying power. I hope this gave you some new information and products to try in the world of these liners. They are really great once you get the hang out them. Last but not least in this series of liner posts will be the cream formulation and I am really excited about it. I know that some of my readers will be unfamiliar with that type of liner and being a lover of it for years, I can't wait to break it down for you! Thanks for reading!

Love, Lacey

Saturday, April 6, 2013

Eyeliner Series: Felt-Tip Eyeliner + Which One Ranks Supreme

     Welcome to the second post in my new eyeliner series! By the end of this post you will have gained extra knowledge regarding this formulation of eyeliners and will (hopefully) have one on your list to try! Using felt-tip eyeliner is an easy way to achieve a classic winged look without the mess of liquid liners. They are easy to control, quick, and fluid when it comes to application.

*If you are new to felt-tip eyeliners, please go check out my comparison here. This will show you what the actual applicator looks like and will give you some great starter brands to try out!*

Let's begin with the felt-tip liners you already own! There aren't many great tips that I can pull out of my beauty arsenal for this formulation. Staying power with these is usually great for all day wear because it isn't as creamy as a pencil liner. However I do have a couple tips...

Tip #1: Storage
When it comes to storing this type of eyeliner, gravity is in your favor! The biggest problem people face with these is that the tip can tend to dry out pretty easily over time. To prevent this as much as possible, store them cap side down to insure that product is rushing into the tip at all times. Make sure the lid is on nice and securely though!

Tip #2: Prime
Yes, you are seeing this tip once again! Priming is really a step that can never hurt when it comes to makeup. What this will do is even out the skin and create a nice, smooth, silky base for the product to glide onto. Whether you are using a face or eye primer for this step, make sure to focus on you lash line.

     After implementing the tips above, if you are still unsatisfied with the staying power or look of your felt-tip eyeliner please keep reading! I have tested the lasting power of the three liners I featured in my comparison post linked above. Which one came out on top... Let's see!

From left to right:


I first swatched the products, then let them set for a good 5 minutes.


Each was tested on how the product smudged (top 1/2) as well as how it preformed while wet (lower 1/2). I did this by rubbing the top portion with medium pressure 3-5 times and doing the same with the lower portion but adding water to my finger.

Ranking Best-Worst:
1. Eyeko (set of 3- black, brown, navy blue $25)- This swatch really impressed me. Not only did the top portion stay put, but the bottom portion held up fairly well to moisture! Out of all three, I saw less fading/running on the lower portion of this swatch. However, I have currently been having some very slight problems with this products applicator. It has gotten a little dry and has bent because the tip is so thin. This is a very common problem with felt-tip liners so please keep that in mind if you are wanting to purchase this product.
2. Physicians Formula ($6.95)- Just like the others in this test, this product's upper swatch did not budge at all when met with my dry finger- the problem came when water was added. This product held up slightly worse than the winner on the lower portion and also faded. 
3. Jordana ($1.99)- This product has me sold for an everyday felt-tip eyeliner but not when I'll be coming into contact with water! This product completely vanished after water was applied and that is why it came in last. As always with felt-tips (especially with the brands I featured) staying power is not a problem if water is not involved. You can see that this formulation also has a feathering problem which is not a good thing for mature skin. Personally, this is not a huge problem for me because the feathering aspect is not noticeable on my lids but it is something to keep in mind.

How well do they remove? Lets find out!
I used one Simple Cleansing Facial Wipe and documented the process from one wipe across - three!
All three are still pretty visible. The lower 1/2 of the Physicians Formula swatch turned blue during this process. Weird!

All three are sill visible but fading.


     As you can see, these liners are very smudge resistant until you add water. If you are someone who needs a little more staying power that isn't a fan water-proof makeup these could be for you! Even though they have a pretty resistant formula, they are still fairly easy to remove and that is why I love felt-tips! 

     So that wraps up this post all about felt-tip liners. I hope this gave you some new ideas to try or even helped you branch out to a new formulation! The world of eyeliner is such a huge place so I hope this helped to shed some light on the very broad array of formulations and staying power! Next in line is a post all dedicated to liquid liners. I will be testing out one brand new formula and comparing it to one very popular, tried and true product currently on the market. Thanks for reading!

Love, Lacey



Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Eyeliner Series: Tips for Long-Lasting Wear + Top Rated Waterproof Eyeliner

     Welcome to my first series of requested blog posts! Over on my Facebook page some people (including my mom) were wanting some tips and tricks on making their eyeliner last all day. I took it upon myself and went out searching for some products to test also! My goal was to provide some advice I have learned from experience to possibly extend the wear of the eyeliner you already own, along with finding the longest wearing product currently on the market. I will be posting four blogs in total touching on each individual formula (Pencils, Felt-tips, Liquids, and Creams) in order of easiest - most difficult formulation to apply.

     Let's begin with the pencils you already own! We all love using what we have since we already spent our hard earned money on it. Sometimes we are not happy with a particular brand or formulation but we can combat that with these tricks of the trade! Maybe it's too hard to glide on easily, or maybe it fades/disappears during the day. Here are my four tips that you can try today!

Tip #1: Finding Your Lid Type and Choosing a Primer
     Oily Lids: If you tend to have oily skin and shiny eyelids that are slick to the touch, you have oily lids. I have heard that the NARS Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base works well at absorbing the extra oil and making your eye makeup last longer. It is a little pricey but you can buy it at Sephora and return it if you aren't satisfied! If you are not wanting to spend $24 on a high-end primer no worries! Just go with Wet N Wild's version that you can find at your local drugstore.
     Normal Lids: Normal lids are just that, normal! If you aren't over oily or dry then you have normal lids. Any eyeshadow primer will work for you, from Wet N Wild's Take on the Day Primer to Urban Decay's Eyeshadow Primer Potion (review here). All you need it to do is create a smooth and even surface for your shadow and liner.
     Dry Lids: If you tend to have dry skin and eyelids that aren't smooth to the touch, you have dry lids like me! You could have patches of extra dry skin along your lash line or outer corner that make it difficult to apply shadow or eyeliner smoothly. I find that applying a lotion to just my lid area helps or using a very heavy moisturizer over night. I have yet to find a perfect moisturizing eyeshadow primer (do they even market one?!) but have had success with the two options above for normal lids.

Tip #2: Prime
     Whether you are priming your entire face before foundation, your eyelids before shadow, or your lash line before eyeliner it is an important step you should not skip. Using a primer evens out your skins texture to prevent creasing and helps the product adhere better to the eye area. This helps boost color pay off and creates staying power instantly. Remember to also prime under the eyelid and onto the lower lash line if you plan on applying liner there as well.

Tip #3: Setting the Product
     In the beauty community "setting" your makeup means applying a powder over top of a creamier product to improve its longevity. You can do this with products for your entire face: liquid foundation+pressed powder, cream eyeshadow+powder eyeshadow, cream blush+powder blush, and even lipstick! With eyeliner the idea is exactly the same: you want to set the liner with a dark shadow to prevent it from moving. Apply your liner as you normally would then pick up a similar color shadow from the drugstore. I would recommend the black shadow in L'Oreal's Hip Duo in Dashing or Rimmel's single eyeshadow in Jet Black for those of you who wear black liner. Apply this shadow directly on top of your liner with an angled brush pushing it into the lash line.

Tip #4: Heat it Up!
Turn to your trusty old blow drier to help make that hard eyeliner glide on easily. Simply take your drier and blow some warm air onto the tip of your eyeliner anywhere from 10-20 seconds. This may take some trial and error but you will find that once you get the perfect amount of heat on that baby it will glide right on. This is also a great technique for cleaning off your eyelash curler. Just heat it up for a few seconds and the gunk comes right off with a tissue!

Now, if these ideas don't do much for you and your personal hatred towards your current eyeliner have no fear! I have picked up a few different brands (along with others I already had) and put them to the test. Here were the results for the ones I tested...

From left to right: 
Almay Intense I-Color Eyeliner in Brown Topaz for Blue Eyes
Sephora Nano Eyeliner in 11 Silver Green


I first swatched the products, then let them set for a good 5 minutes.


Each was tested on how the product smudged (top 1/2) as well as how it preformed while wet (lower 1/2). I did this by rubbing the top portion with medium pressure 3-5 times and doing the same with the lower portion but adding water to my finger.

Ranking Best-Worst:
1. Milani ($6.99)- This was the hands down winner! It stood up very well against smudging and moisture. It was very opaque and glided on very easily which is essential for pencil eyeliners. It claims to provide all day wear as well as being smudge-proof and during the test, that rang true! You can easily smudge this out with a q-tip before it sets for a nice smokey look also. This brand comes in many shades which is great for those of you who like pops of color.
2. Maybelline ($6.39)- This and Stila's liner were neck and neck! This one came out on top just because I saw a TINY bit more smudging toward the top of Stilas swatch. This product claims to be sumdgeproof and waterproof for 16 hours but I didn't find that to be true. Even though it didn't smudge considerably, it still faded in both tests and that's enough evidence for me to dismiss those claims. Even though this is the purple option it still has very nice color payoff and is really creamy. It is a liner that requires no sharpener which is awesome for people on the go.
3. Stila ($20.00)- I received this liner in my Birchbox a few months back and loved it's color! I decided to include it in this test because it claims to be waterproof and of course there is a black option. I saw a little smudging towards the upper portion of the swatch but it held up very well regarding the wet portion. For pops of color during summertime wear this product would be ideal.
4. Urban Decay ($19.00)- This was not as black as the Milani version but held up fairly well. This is a cult favorite and there is even now a darker more opaque black option called Perversion. It claims to be waterproof and says that it "dries down to a long-lasting finish that WILL NOT budge". I found that even though this product didn't smear or smudge, it faded and I consider that budging!
5. Neutrogena ($7.49)- This product claims to "transform into a long-lasting finish that won't budge". I will say that this did okay in the smudging department but I ranked it at #5 because of the opacity! I bought the black shade and it come off as more of a charcoal grey. Just compare the color payoff to Milani's formula! In the beauty community, we all look for the blackest most opaque black eyeliners and that is the main reason I ranked it as low as I did. However, this would be a good choice for you if you prefer a softer looking liner for your lash line. 
6. Rimmel ($3.99)- Being that this was the least expensive option out of all eight... at least it's not last! This was an old formula that I had in my collection from many years ago so make sure to take that into consideration as well as the fact that it is not marketed as a long wearing product. This products selling points are that it's supposed to "not tug or skip on the delicate skin around your eyes". This color was gorgeous and would be another one that would be perfect for summer- as long as your not swimming! It faded and smudged with and without moisture so this wouldn't be suitable for all day wear especially for someone with oily lids.
7. Sephora ($5.00)- I will admit, I have not gotten into Sephora's makeup line hardly at all. I actually received this liner with either a 100 or 500 point perk a few years ago. This is another product that is not marketed as a long-lasting product and I can see why. It nearly disappeared after being rubbed and smudged all over the place after the second test getting color everywhere. They do have a wide variety of 21 shades, including both neutral shades and fun, colorful ones.
8. Almay ($7.99)- Rounding up this list of eight is poor Almay. This was another one of those liners that I had in my collection that I had nearly forgot about and I wonder why?! This product did not set at all even after giving it a whole five minutes. It completely moved and smudged during the test with and without water. I will say that the initial color of this liner is very beautiful and perfect for my blue eyes but that is my only compliment.

How well do they remove? Lets find out!
I used one Simple Cleansing Facial Wipe and documented the process from one wipe across - four.
Milani, Urban Decay, Maybelline, Stila, and Rimmel are still fairly intact.

Milani and Stila have made it through another round!

Going, going....

GONE! 
(well, for the most part)

As you can see, even though many of these liners are marketed as long-wearing products that won't budge they are still pretty easy to remove with a makeup wipe. This is a great aspect because even though you want them to last your entire workday, you can still remove them without blinding yourself before bed.

     So that my friends was my first huge eyeliner testing spree that took weeks to execute and write. Thank you for being so patient with me and this process. I want to make sure that with each of my posts I am sharing my honest and final decisions with all of you. Sometimes I can make decisions quickly and other times I can't, so thank you for holding in there. Within the next week I will be posting the second blog in this series all about felt-tip liners and I'll let you in on a little secret- it won't be nearly this long! As always leave me any questions or comments below and please share this with friends and family. Everyone can use a few eyeliner tips!

Please make sure to follow me over on Bloglovin'.
You can either click the link here or under the Blog Archive to your right!
Love, Lacey


Saturday, March 23, 2013

Physicians Formula Organic Wear Jumbo Lash vs. FakeOut Mascara

     Even though I have gone through countless drugstore mascaras I had never tried one from Physicians Formula. I had heard amazing things about their Jumbo Lash mascara and decided to give it a try. While at CVS I saw the newer FakeOut version and decided to do a comparison. Both versions have an extremely dry formula that I thought I would really enjoy. When it comes to dry vs. wet mascaras, I always find myself favoring the drier formulas. Here is my comparison...

Physicians Formula Organic Wear 100% Origin Jumbo Lash Mascara:
Price: $9.99
Size: 0.26 OZ.
Shade: Ultra Black
Marketed As: "A mascara where 100% of the total ingredients are from natural origin and 70% of the total ingredients are from organic farming. This offers 100% dramatic volume and glamor with the help of the Organisoy® which moisturizers and nourishes lashes. It also includes Eco-Olive®, a natural antioxidant which shields lashes from harsh environmental aggressors. Hypoallergenic, fragrance free, and optamologist approved".
Directions: "Sweep mascara brush from lash base to tips.  Apply multiple coats for added volume. Can easily be washed off with soap and water or removed with Physicians Formula Eye Makeup Remover Pads or Lotions".

Physicians Formula Organic Wear 100% Natural Origin FakeOut Mascara:
Price: $9.99
Size: 0.26 OZ.
Shade: Black
Marketed As: "The 1st EVER mascara with 100% natural origin lash extension fibers for the full-on fringe of false lashes without irritation. Innovative formula amplifies lash volume, length, and curl. Oversized brush creates a fabulously false lash effect instantly! 100% of the total ingredients are from natural origin and 70% are from organic farming. Hypoallergenic, fragrance free, safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, and optamologist approved".
Directions: "Sweep mascara brush from lash base to tips. Apply multiple coats for added volume".
 Product Photos:







Applicator Details
     Jumbo Lash (left): This mascara has a very thick, plastic wand with short bristles. The brush is wider in the center then begins tapering in around the first and last four rows. There is no pivotal point on the wand and the bristles are fairly flexible.

     FakeOut (right): This brush is very similar to Jumbo Lash. However, there are some very small difference when you look closely. This wand is slightly less thick than the other and also has no pivotal point. The base where the bristles attach is thinner on this wand making the bristles appear longer. This brush is rounder through the middle but tapers just the same as Jumbo Lash towards the ends.

With both brushes bristle placement is very similar and they are the same length.

Application Photos: Natural lashes with no mascara- three coats.
Note: My eyelashes are not curled.

            -Jumbo Lash-                                                                                              -FakeOut-












     I hands down was disappointed with both of these mascaras. They did not live up to all of the hype that I had been hearing and that shocked me! The formula is very different than anything I had tried but both are pretty similar with regard to everything except the end result. If you are someone who values organic products, this could be for you. I will give this brand props for having the only drugstore organic mascara on the market that I know of. Personally, I don't go out of my way in search of organic makeup products so that wasn't a huge selling point for me. I feel like each of these mascaras would cater to an individual preference with one being more dramatic and one looking more natural. Here are my overall thoughts...

Physicians Formula Organic Wear 100% Origin Jumbo Lash Mascara:
Overall Application: Application regarding the brush was similar to any other plastic bristled brush for me. I felt as though it was poking my eye and found it uncomfortable during application. It could be the mix of the wand and formula but I found that if any of this got into my eye, it really bothered me! The brush didn't do much for the formula and vice versa in my opinion.
Overall Color: I had nothing negative to say about the color of this product. It was very black and coated my lashes evenly with color.
Overall Formula: As I mentioned before this was a very odd formulation for me. It was VERY dry and not smooth during application. Even though removing it was a breeze it felt like it never set onto my lashes. I tend to have itchy eyes and will gently touch my lashes throughout the day and found that when I did, my fingers would stick to my lashes and product would rub off on them. I hated this aspect because after I had taken the time to separate my lashes during application, if I pinched a few together during the day they would stick together and stay that way. Like I said before, this aspect might be the reason it removes so easily, but I'd rather it set and be harder to remove. As for my lashes I would have to add at least two coats to be happy with this mascara and sometimes I don't have the time to layer on multiple coats! I felt like two almost wasn't enough but three began to look clumpy. Oddly enough, this formula made my lashes longer and fuller than the FakeOut formula which was supposed to create a "fake lash look". I liked the length but the overall effect was too "spidery" for me. This formula would be best for someone who likes very prominent and dramatic lashes everyday. This mascara really coats on the product and for me, it is just too unnatural looking for daily wear.
Overall Packaging: As for both packagings I was very unimpressed. I like to put one coat of mascara on, wait about a minute, then keep building for more volume and length. With this packaging I couldn't stand the tube upright very easily in between coats. The bottom is very narrow and would cause the mascara to fall over multiple times. Where you hold the wand (the lid) ended up being very awkward in my hands and I had to keep repositioning the wand to get a comfortable hold. Other than that it is very eye-catching. The bright, metallic, curvy packaging is very neat and different than other drugstore mascara packaging.
Overall Scent: Fragrance free? What does that exactly mean? To me I always thought it meant that no fragrance would be detected. However, with this formula it could mean that no artificial fragrance was added. This has a moderate organic grassy smell that isn't very pleasant to me. I tend to like herbal smells (hello Kiehl's shampoo anyone?) but this didn't do it for me.
Overall Wear: I didn't have any problems with wear. It didn't smudge, transfer, fade, or flake.

Physicians Formula Organic Wear 100% Natural Origin FakeOut Mascara:
Overall Application: The over all application was very similar to Jumbo Lash because the brushes are almost identical. I didn't notice any differences while applying this mascara even though this brush is slightly slimmer with longer bristles. I also had the same problem with this formula as Jumbo Lash in the fact that when it got into my eye it bothered me more than any other mascara I've tried. It wasn't a burning sensation by any means, it just felt irritated and gritty.
Overall Color: I felt as though this black was not as opaque or deep in color than the Jumbo Lash mascara. I am aware that this shade was "Black" instead of "Ultra Black" so I understand that there was a slight difference in color. However, I have said this before when it comes to drugstore mascara shades but please make this more simple for the consumer. When buying both mascaras I didn't notice CVS carrying the "Ultra Black" version of this mascara so I was a little confused.
Overall Formula: I found this formula less dry than it's competitor but the differences do not stop there. I will say that this particular formula quickly built up more volume, looked less spidery, and was more natural looking than Jumbo Lash. I was let down with the lengthening aspect of this formula especially when comparing it to the other version. Out of the two this would be the best choice for people who like more natural looking lashes. However, I will admit that there are better drugstore alternatives (CoverGirl Clump Crusher) on the market if that is what you prefer.
Overall Packaging: Same as above explanation. It hardly stood up in between coats and was awkward in my hand during application.
Overall Scent: I found this scent pretty much identical to Jumbo Lash. It also claims to be fragrance free and smells very organic and grassy.
Overall Wear: I found this products wear the same as it's competitor. I had no major problems and it didn't seem to smudge, transfer, fade, or flake.

Bottom Line: I was very disappointed with my first two Physicians Formula mascara purchases. For being a slightly more expensive than the typical drugstore brand I was looking for better quality and was let down. It's quite funny, I liked the lengthening and curling benefits of Jumbo Lash and the softness and natural looking qualities of FakeOut- are we sure these formulas didn't get switched during packaging?! If there was a formula that combined those aspects I would love to give it a try but until then I will be returning both of these mascaras. I am also not looking to purchase another mascara from this brand in the near future because of three reasons...
1. Extremely dry formula
2. Brush
3. Packaging
4. Already own better alternatives


P.S. I have heard through the grapevine that Blogger is doing away with Google Friend Connect which is very unfortunate! This means that in order to continue following my blog you will need to visit this link here. For those of you that take the time to do this extra step, thank you from the bottom of my heart. Even though I am new at the whole blogging thing, I love hearing from the very positive and inspirational girls I have been able to connect with through this blogging community. Thank you!

Love, Lacey


Saturday, February 23, 2013

A High and Low End Eyeshadow Primer

     I used eyeshadow primer for the first time a few years ago and haven't put it down since. Well, maybe that's a little dramatic but I love the stuff! It is essentially meant to extend the life of your eye makeup, prevent creasing, and improve the color vibrancy of your eyeshadow. I have only tried the two most popular brands (Urban Decay and Too Faced) but as soon as I found out about a drugstore version I couldn't wait to get my hands on it.

     Wet N Wild just released their new line featuring Fergie called Center Stage. It includes everything from eyeshadow and mascara to lip products and nail polish- not to mention a new eye shadow primer! For the sake of this post I mainly will be reviewing the product but also will be comparing it to the formula of the very popular Urban Decay Primer Potion.

Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion:
Price: $20
Size: Full Size is 0.37 OZ and the sample size (pictured above) is 0.13 OZ.
Shade: Original 
Shade Selection: 4
Marketed As: "Urban Decay's #1 best selling product. Apply before your eyeshadow for more vibrant crease-free color that lasts for 24 hours".

Wet N Wild Take on the Day Primer:
Price: $4.99
Size: 0.34 OZ.
Shade: For My Primas
Shade Selection: 1
Marketed As: "This revolutionary shade-adjusting technology starts out white and adjusts to match your exact skin tone. Unique primer properties smooth skin texture for perfect application".

Product Photos:


Urban Decay Primer Potion contains a doe foot applicator.
I use this to apply the product to my eyelid and blend with my finger.
*Urban Decay has since changed their packaging- it's now very similar to the Wet N Wild product. Please check out Urban Decay's link, which is provided above to view the new packaging*

The Wet N Wild Take on the Day Primer has very simple, yet effective packaging. You easily squeeze some product out onto your finger then apply it to your eyelid and blend.

-Urban Decay (left) and Wet N Wild (right)-

Application Photos:

-Urban Decay Primer Potion-
It cancels out any discoloration and redness creating the perfect canvas for eyeshadow.

-Wet N Wild's Take on the Day Primer-
This formula is less opaque so it does't leave the eyelid completely flawless.

Here is a photo showing the overall look after applying eyeshadow
Wet N Wild (left) and Urban Decay (right)
*I used the CoverGirl Shimmering Sands palette*

     I was very impressed with how this drugstore formula faired against it's very popular competitor. Here are my overall thoughts...

Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion:
Overall Application: There are die hard fans out there for this stuff and I understand why! It's great- just that simple. The application is very smooth and it blends out easily. I would be careful though because it does set pretty quickly. If you don't blend it out within 30 seconds it hardly budges. That happened to me when I was taking these photos!
Overall Color: I have gotten the chance to also try one of their new shades- Greed. It was very nice but I seem to prefer the original color. To me, I don't feel the need to have multiple shades of primer because I'm just going to cover them with eyeshadow. I want the true color of my shadow to show, not a mix of shadow and primer. I do commend Urban Decay for coming out with different shades though. They would be pretty worn alone and would also cater to a wider range of skin tones.
Overall Formula: It is blendable but not too silky. It absorbs quickly and does a great job of canceling out any discoloration on the eyelid. 
Overall Packaging: I was a fan of the doe foot applicator but since they have changed the packaging, I see why they did. Many customers were complaining that they could not get all of the product out of the curves of the tube with the doe foot applicator. Once I need to repurchase this product I am sure I will enjoy the newer packaging.
Overall Wear: This product is at the center of every eyeshadow primer conversation and for a reason, it does exactly what it is supposed to do. It boosts the color of the eyeshadow and made the overall eye look last all day without creasing.  

Wet N Wild Take On The Day Primer:
Overall Application: Application for this primer was great. I actually found my self applying too much product so a little goes a long way. It also blends nicely.
Overall Color: The product doesn't come out white like it claims- it is more of a very light, flesh tone color. I also don't think it "adjusted" to my particular skin tone but it did blend in without being noticeable.
Overall Formula: This product is more watery and liquidy than its competitor. It actually has a very similar consistency to Too Faced Shadow Insurance- the other most popular eyeshadow primer. Even though it didn't leave my eyelid flawless, it did combat most of the redness and discoloration. For me, the finish of this primer was totally acceptable.
Overall Packaging: I liked this packaging but I did have one complaint. The opening where the product comes out is fairly big. It didn't cause too many problems but the product does come out fast when you squeeze the tube. 
Overall Wear: I was very pleased with the wear of this product! It held up great and just as well as a high-end formula. When I wore them side by side I noticed no differences in color vibrancy, creasing, or wear.

Bottom Line: If you are a fan of wearing eyeshadow and don't own a primer, you should! It is an extra step that takes only a few seconds but makes a huge impact. With this new Wet N Wild product being the first drugstore eyeshadow primer that I have tried, I am very happy! If you are in need or are wanting to try an eyeshadow primer than this drugstore one is perfect for the job. It is readily available at any drugstore where Wet N Wild is sold and is a forth of the price of both popular high-end brands. I will be sticking with the Wet N Wild drugstore formula and will be reaching it for it when my samples of high-end primers run out for two reasons...
1. PRICE
2. It gives the same result as a high-end formula.


Love, Lacey